Document Feedback - Review and Comment
Step 1 of 4: Comment on Document
How to make a comment?
1. Use this to open a comment box for your chosen Section, Part, Heading or clause.
2. Type your feedback into the comments box and then click "save comment" button located in the lower-right of the comment box.
3. Do not open more than one comment box at the same time.
4. When you have finished making comments proceed to the next stage by clicking on the "Continue to Step 2" button at the very bottom of this page.
Important Information
During the comment process you are connected to a database. Like internet banking, the session that connects you to the database may time-out due to inactivity. If you do not have JavaScript running you will recieve a message to advise you of the length of time before the time-out. If you have JavaScript enabled, the time-out is lengthy and should not cause difficulty, however you should note the following tips to avoid losing your comments or corrupting your entries:
-
DO NOT jump between web pages/applications while logging comments.
-
DO NOT log comments for more than one document at a time. Complete and submit all comments for one document before commenting on another.
-
DO NOT leave your submission half way through. If you need to take a break, submit your current set of comments. The system will email you a copy of your comments so you can identify where you were up to and add to them later.
-
DO NOT exit from the interface until you have completed all three stages of the submission process.
Talent, Recruitment and Appointment Procedure
Section 1 - Introduction
(1) The University of Newcastle (
(2) This document outlines the procedural requirements for the recruitment, assessment, selection, appointment and onboarding processes of professional, teaching and academic
Section 2 - Scope
(3) This Procedure applies to the recruitment, assessment, selection, appointment, and onboarding of all
(4) This Procedure does not apply to the recruitment, assessment, selection, appointment and onboarding of
- the
University's controlled entities ; - off shore campuses;
- academic staff seeking appointment to a higher academic level in their current role (please see Academic Promotion Policy);
- honorary academic appointments (please see Honorary Academic Titles and Visiting Appointments Policy);
- Laureate Professor appointments (please see Appointment as Laureate Professor Policy); or
- volunteers (please see Volunteer (including Volunteer Researcher) Policy).
(5) This procedure must be read in conjunction with the Talent, Recruitment and Appointment Policy.
Top of PageSection 3 - Definitions
(6) In the context of this document the following definitions apply:
Term | Definition |
---|---|
Academic staff | Means individuals appointed to an academic position in accordance with the University of Newcastle Academic Staff and Teachers Enterprise Agreement. This definition specifically excludes honorary academic or conjoint title holders. |
Centre | Means |
Continuing employment | All employment that is not contingent, fixed-term or casual employment, and for which there is no set date for the employment to cease. |
Fixed-term employment | Employment for a specified term in accordance with the relevant Enterprise Agreement. |
Casual employment | Employment paid on an hourly basis in accordance with the relevant Enterprise Agreement. |
Sessional academic appointment | Employment of casual academic staff in accordance with the Academic Staff and Teaching Enterprise Agreement. |
Contingent employment | Employment provided from identifiable funding external to the |
Senior executive appointments |
A senior executive appointment may include:
|
Redeployment | Where a detached |
Request | The formal request to recruit for a position or appoint a |
Appointable candidate | A |
Categories of merit |
The categories of merit that
|
Identified position | A position which requires a particular attribute (genuine occupational requirement) such as Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander, gender, disability etc. |
Targeted position | A position that does not require a particular attribute but the |
Market/Role Loading | A discretionary market loading, or monetary allowance, where there is a clear need to enhance the |
University Institute | As defined by the Guidelines to define Units, Centres and University Institutes. |
Section 4 - Planning to Recruit
(7) Recruitment to a role will generally be in response to a current vacancy, impending vacancy or the creation of a new position.
(8) The
(9) The
Role Design
(10) A Position Description (PD) is required for all appointments that will be greater than six (6) months. The
(11) The PD will be reviewed and/or evaluated by Human Resource Services in the following circumstances:
- the position is new; or
- there has been significant change to the existing position.
(12) A Statement of Duties is required for all appointments less than six (6) months, which should describe the key activities and responsibilities for the role. The
Recruitment and Sourcing Strategy
(13) Human Resource Services in consultation with the
Table A - Recruitment and Sourcing Strategy Type
Strategy Type | Description |
---|---|
Internal |
For appointments where the role is open to |
External |
For appointments where the role is open to |
Intra-team recruitment | For appointments where the role is open to |
Direct appointment | Appointment of a |
Sessional Academic Expression of Interest (EOI) | To create a register of suitable sessional academic staff, open to |
Appointment by invitation |
Used in exceptional circumstances for the appointment of outstanding academic or professional
a. where the proposed appointment is required in a short timeframe to secure an outstanding
b. where the proposed appointment would provide a major competitive advantage to the
c. where any breach of confidentiality would place the appointee and the appointment at
d. in other exceptional circumstances.
Appointment by invitation must be approved by the Vice-Chancellor. |
Executive search firm or recruitment agency engagement | An external provider is engaged, at an additional cost to the |
Section 5 - General Procedural Requirements
(14) The
(15) Advertising of positions must be in accordance with the provisions of the Talent, Recruitment and Appointment Policy and the relevant enterprise agreement.
(16) Where a suitable
- the appointment is not a result of a previous competitive process whereby the
candidate was identified as an appointablecandidate ; - the appointment is less than twelve (12) months duration (including any extensions);
- the appointment is less than twelve (12) months when a specific skill set is needed for a strategic project, with the option to extend this for a further period of 12 months as approved by the Division or
College Leader; - the appointment is for a grant or contract funded role of less than or equal to three (3) years. A request to appoint for the duration of a grant over three (3) years can be made to the Pro Vice-Chancellor for approval.
(17) For recruitment to grant funded positions, the
- verifying the
candidate is permitted to be employed using funds awarded from the grant; and - ensuring that where a specific
researcher is named in a grant application, that their recruitment is through direct appointment.
Appointment by Invitation
(18) An appointment by invitation must be initiated in writing by an Executive or
(19) The Vice-Chancellor will consider any relevant material which may include but is not limited to:
- a statement by the Executive or
Senior staff member as to why the nominated candidate is important to the strategic direction and reputation of theUniversity ; - the individual’s curriculum vitae and qualifications;
- a brief statement from the
candidate (if requested by the Vice-Chancellor); - written referee reports from at least two (2) referees as determined by the Executive or
Senior staff member in consultation with the Vice-Chancellor; and - other documents that may be requested by the Vice-Chancellor.
(20) The Vice-Chancellor will either approve or not approve an offer of employment by invitation in consultation with the Chief People and Culture Officer.
Appointment to Academic Administrative or Managerial Roles
(21) Recruitment, selection and appointment to academic administrative or managerial roles (eg Deputy Head of School, Academic Authority) shall be made separately from appointment to an academic level.
(22) Successful external
Section 6 - Sourcing
Advertising
(23) Prior to advertising a position, the
- the key requirements of the role;
- the ability to consider non-Australian working rights
candidates ; - equity, diversity and inclusion considerations; and
- associated remuneration and benefits, including if a market loading is applicable.
(24) Internal advertising will be used where required by the relevant
(25) An advertising campaign may include internal and external job postings, including online and other mediums.
(26) A job advertisement will be prepared by the
(27) Appropriate adjustments will be made during the application process for
(28) All
Section 7 - Assessment and Selection
(29) The minimum assessment and selection techniques to be used are shown in Table B. Where an exception to these is to be made, approval will be required by the Senior Manager, Talent Acquisition.
(30)
Table B – Selection and Assessment Techniques
Level / Role Type | Minimum Selection Techniques | Optional Assessment Techniques |
---|---|---|
All positions |
Interview/formal discussion
Two (2) Reference Checks (except for intra-team recruitment who do not require a reference check)
Required pre-employment checks
Job talk – required for all academic roles where the appointment is greater than or expected to be greater than 12 months, and is not a
Benchmarking report – required for academic roles where the appointment is greater than or expected to be greater than 12 months, and is not a |
Initial Screening interview
Site visit
Meet and greet(s)
Leadership assessment
Work sample test
Seminars/presentation
Skills assessments
Background screening
Psychometric or other testing
Follow up interview
Pre-employment medical assessment |
Selection Committee
(31) A Selection Committee is required for
(32) Selection Committees (regardless of position level or classification) must:
- for all positions:
- include representation from a specific diversity group if the position is an identified or targeted position; and
- ensure all members have completed relevant training at least annually as defined by the Chief People and Culture Officer, to ensure understanding of critical considerations such as bias and diversity awareness;
- for non-academic positions:
- comprise a minimum of three (3) members, with gender balance unless otherwise approved by the Hiring Manager on recommendation by the Senior Manager, Talent Acquisition (please see Gender Inclusive Membership of University Committees Policy);
- have an appointed Chair who is at least one (1) level above the advertised position;
- include one member who is external to the work unit recruiting who is nominated by the Chair and who may be external to the
University ; - ensure all members are at or above the level of the advertised position, except where specialist knowledge in a field or role is required;
- for academic positions:
- comprise a minimum of four (4) members, with gender balance unless otherwise approved by the Hiring Manager on recommendation by the Senior Manager, Talent Acquisition (please see Gender Inclusive Membership of University Committees Policy);
- comprise members who are at or above the level of the role being recruited;
- include an internal expert and expert panel member external to the unit/
School ; - include the Pro Vice-Chancellor Indigenous Strategy and Leadership where the position is an Indigenous targeted position;
- must be chaired by a Senior Executive and comply with the Academic Position Selection Committee roles in Table C below.
(33) The Selection Committee must abide by the Conflict of Interest Policy and Conflict of Interest Procedure.
Table C – Academic Position Selection Committee Roles
Role | Level A-C | Level D | Level E |
---|---|---|---|
Chair | Must be the College Pro Vice-Chancellor, unless a Head of School or Deputy Dean / Assistant Dean Teaching or Research is nominated by the College Pro Vice-Chancellor. | Must be the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic) or Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Research and Innovation) unless a College Pro Vice-Chancellor is nominated by the Deputy Vice-Chancellor. | Must be the Vice-Chancellor, unless a Deputy Vice-Chancellor is nominated by the Vice-Chancellor. |
Minimum Membership Requirements |
- Head of School (or nominee if acting as Chair).
- Senior lecturer external to the
- Any additional members as appointed by the College Pro Vice-Chancellor or Vice-Chancellor (as appropriate). |
- College Pro Vice-Chancellor, unless a Deputy Dean / Assistant Dean Teaching or Research is nominated by the College Pro Vice-Chancellor.
- Head of School, Institute or Centre.
- Professor external to the
- Any additional members as nominated by the Pro Vice-Chancellor. |
- Deputy Vice-Chancellor.
- Pro Vice-Chancellor (College and/or other).
- Head of School, Institute or Centre.
- Deputy Dean / Assistant Dean Teaching or Research as appropriate.
- Professor external to the University appointed by the convenor (as appropriate).
- Senior business/industry person appointed by the convenor (as appropriate).
- Any additional members as appointed by the Deputy Vice-Chancellor or Vice-Chancellor (as appropriate). |
Shortlisting
(34) Prior to shortlisting taking place, the
(35) Shortlisting will be undertaken by either:
- the Selection Committee;
- the
Hiring Manager ; or - a recruitment agency or executive search firm if engaged.
(36) Applications from
(37) At the conclusion of shortlisting, all
Job Talk
(38) A Job Talk is a formal presentation by a
(39) Invited attendees will typically comprise a range of academics from the relevant
(40) Feedback from the Job Talk will be provided to the Selection Committee and will be considered as part of the assessment process.
(41) Job Talks will be arranged by the hiring area in consultation with the Talent Acquisition Specialist.
Interview
(42) An interview or formal discussion provides an opportunity to ask questions, seek clarification and gather information from
(43) Appropriate adjustments during the interview process will be made for
(44) The Selection Committee Chair, with the support of the Talent Acquisition Specialist if requested, will prepare suitable questions for interview.
(45) Each
Optional Assessment Techniques
(46) A range of assessment techniques may be used to form part of the assessment and selection process at the discretion of the Selection Committee Chair or
(47) Optional assessment techniques are to be coordinated by the Talent Acquisition Team.
Reference Checks
(48) A minimum of two (2) reference checks is required for all appointments, with the exception of intra-team recruitment where a reference check is not required. The reference checks should provide sufficient information to confirm the
(49) Reference checks must be conducted before an offer of employment is made.
(50) The Selection Committee Chair (or nominee) or the
(51) An interviewer or Selection Committee member cannot be a referee, unless otherwise approved by the Senior Manager, Talent Acquisition.
(52) Evidence of completed reference checks will be provided to Human Resource Services for record management purposes.
Selection
(53) At the conclusion of all assessment and selection techniques, all available information gathered on each
- determine which
candidate (s) meet the requirements of the role and can be deemed appointable; - where there is more than one (1) appointable
candidate , rank thecandidates in order of suitability for the position; - seek further information on a
candidate to make a determination, which may include additional assessment techniques; and/or - deem a
candidate not appointable if they do not demonstrate the required categories of merit for the role.
(54) If a Selection Committee is convened, the Chair:
- will provide their feedback following the comments from other Selection Committee members; and
- will ensure a Selection Committee Report is prepared and endorsed by all committee members at the completion of the recruitment process.
(55) As part of the selection process, each
(56) If no
Section 8 - Appointment and Onboarding
Approval
(57) Appointment of a preferred
- Professional
staff positions – in accordance with the Delegations Register; - Academic
staff positions:- ≤ Level E – Vice-Chancellor, subject to Council Reserved Matters;
- ≤ Level D – Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic), or Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Research and Innovation) for
research only and/orresearch grant funded appointments; and - ≤ Level C – College Pro Vice-Chancellor for fixed term appointments subject to funding conditions as defined in the Schedule of Vice-Chancellor’s Operational sub-delegations.
(58) Where the
Pre-employment Checks (excluding references)
(59) Human Resource Services will conduct all necessary pre-employment checks prior to commencement of the successful
- Identity checks;
- Working rights checks;
- Criminal records checks;
- Medical checks;
- Verification of qualifications;
- Working with Children checks; and
- Designated Security checks.
(60) Appointments are conditional upon the satisfactory outcome of any pre-employment checks.
Market/Role Loading
(61) Where the Selection Committee determines that a market loading is essential to secure the preferred
(62) Extensions to market loading payments must be approved by a relevant
Offer of Employment
(63) A letter of offer will be prepared and checked by Human Resource Services, authorised by the
(64) Where the
(65) Details of relocation assistance offered to the
(66) The letter of offer must be signed by the
(67) Where the preferred
- progress to the next appointable
candidate (pending mandatory pre-employment checks); - reconvene the Selection Committee; or
- review the recruitment and sourcing strategy, in consultation with Human Resource Services.
Onboarding
(68) All appointed
(69) The
(70) The
(71) The
Section 9 - Secondment
(72)
(73)
(74) A secondment letter of offer, including conditions of the
(75) Commencement in the new position will occur two (2) weeks after agreement with relevant parties.
(76) In exceptional circumstances, the Chief People and Culture Officer may approve:
- a further extension up to a twelve (12) month secondment period; and/or
- an extension to a
secondment period beyond twelve (12) months.
Inbound and Outbound Secondments
(77)
(78) A business case for an inbound or
(79) A relevant
(80) If approved, the Head of School, supervisor or equivalent will prepare the inbound or
(81) The details and conditions of the
(82)
Section 10 - Record Keeping
(83) Records are retained by Human Resource Services for all stages of the recruitment, assessment, selection, appointment and onboarding processes in accordance with the Records Governance Policy.
(84) All recruitment records pertaining to the recruitment process must be provided to Human Resource Services at the time of the request to appoint a
Section 11 - Relaxing Provision
(85) During organisational change, recruitment processes designed to cover the requirements of the change process will be described in the proposal paper regarding the change, and administered in line with the relevant staff Enterprise Agreements and the principles of the Talent, Recruitment and Appointment Policy.